What would happen if you were given a second chance to meet someone? Cal Logan is shocked to recognize Nicole Bentley in a coffee shop thousands of miles away from their hometown. They graduated together a year ago, and since then no one has heard from her. It's just that this girl isn't Nicole. She looks exactly like Cal's childhood sweetheart, but her name is Nyelle Preston and she has no idea who Cal is. Nyelle's personality is the exact opposite of Nicole's. Cal develops an irresistible attraction to her and falls completely for her. However, Nyelle behaves extremely mysteriously. And the more Cal realizes what he's hiding, the less he wants to know the truth. As the secrets of the past surface and collide with the present, one thing becomes abundantly clear: nothing is what it seems.